Writing Retreats - A Fair Comparison?

Updated: 17 hours ago
In this age of AI-powered search-engines, finding the right retreat is increasingly difficult. Just this morning we carried out our own quick search on ChatGTP - seeking 'a writing retreat for novices'. The results were pleasing but also misleading: A Place to Write and Arvon Foundation courses were both recommended but without any clear explanation of the fundamental differences between each organisation's residential retreat offer. This might seem surprising given the distinct differences in our respective offers.

This blog, therefore, is our response to the search undertaken this morning and the issues created by AI. It offers a fair comparison that writers thinking of joining either organisation's residential retreats need to be aware of. The comparison is based on three primary sources: 1) our own offer, 2) the Arvon website's description of Arvon retreats (October 2026), and 3) the observations made by the many writers we have spoken to who have enjoyed residential retreats at both Arvon and A Place to Write in the past 18 months. But don't take our word, their word, or the word of a generative AI summary for it: research both our offers - and those of other retreat centres - for yourself!
Locations
On this feature of a modern retreat centre there seems to be great similarity between A Place to Write and Arvon: Arvon's 'three writing houses' are described as 'historic, beautiful and peaceful, but with a distinct character' (Arvon website). Our own property, likewise, has history, character, beauty and tranquillity. Walks into nature are available from the properties at both retreats. At A Place to Write we offer a guided walk to an ancient hill-fort on one afternoon, while it is not clear from the Arvon website if a guided walk is offered by Arvon.
Accommodation
This depends on where your course takes place - for example one of Arvon's three houses has ensuite rooms but the other two are 'mainly shared bathrooms', shared by 'up to five people' (Arvon website). All our rooms at A Place to Write are fully ensuite with a bath and a shower over the bath.
There are so many varied details in the accommodation offer from both retreat organisations, however, that the only fair way to compare is to send you to the Arvon page for FAQs about their accommodation, while confirming that at A Place to Write:
a) our historic mountainside property unfortunately creates accessibility challenges for those with mobility issues, and we cannot currently provide adequate access for wheelchair users, so we recommend you contact us before booking;
b) we do allow dogs on most retreats - let us know if you are allergic before booking;
c) we do provide towels and toiletries (and a bathrobe) and these will be replaced during the week if required;
d) we do have ultrafast wifi across the property.
A footnote: we were informed this week that, at least on some of Arvon's retreats, there is no housekeeping team onsite overnight - meaning a call to an emergency number if something goes wrong, like locking yourself out of your room. At A Place to Write, Wendy and I live onsite (away from the guest accommodation) so are always on hand to help out and sort any issues that may arise.
Catering
This is the first significant point of difference for a writer, which potential guests should be aware of: at A Place to Write we provide ALL the catering during your stay, from main meals (three per day) to session refreshments (twice per day) to refreshments in your room (all day!). The meals are planned to suit each group's precise dietary needs, frequently with bespoke dishes for individuals with allergies or specific requests. Refreshments are equally bespoke where possible (e.g. a selection of gluten free biscuits, etc).
At Arvon the menu is also put together according to the group's dietary needs but the principal point of difference is that guests at Arvon retreats, on one evening of their stay, participate in preparing and cooking a meal, under supervision, for the rest of the group. Arvon say this is 'an essential part of an Arvon week' (Arvon website) and we have certainly encountered writers who have loved the team activity and a chance to cook. However, this element is not for everyone and it is important to recognise that cooking a meal is a central feature of the catering arrangement at Arvon but not at A Place to Write.
Tutoring, Support and Expertise
This is the greatest point of difference between the two retreat offers. And while the differences are very easy to quantify, the value of each retreat offer will be different according to your own personality, ambitions, outlook, and experience.
At Arvon the retreat workshops are typically run by 'acclaimed and prizewinning writers' who 'share their insights into building a writing practice' (Arvon website). At A Place to Write the principal tutor is Dr Nic Brownlie whose unique approach to writing is based on theatrical approaches to character and plot, text and subtext, structure and form. Nic is supported by prize-winning author, editor and writers' mentor, Emily Barroso, whose knowledge of the industry is second to none.

Nic's unique theatre-informed approach is our USP on tutored retreats for writers of fiction and non-fiction. It is not available at Arvon. On untutored retreats, too, Nic is currently available for informal conversations which can open even an experienced traditionally-published writer's eyes to the value of a theatre-informed approach to writing. And, what's more, starting in November 2026, we launched our online support offer: a tiered choice of online sessions providing writing and manuscript development options that are designed to help writers from our retreats (and others) to maintain their momentum after their retreat finishes. This, again, is personally led by Dr. Nic Brownlie.
The Last Night
While the last night on both organisations' residential retreats involves 'sharing of work produced or honed during the week' (Arvon website), it is only at A Place to Write that these readings take place in candlelight. Why does that matter? Because candlelight provides a unique environment which writers on our retreats recognise as providing the perfect setting for a shared experience enjoyed by a small community of writers. We can not, in all fairness, compare this candlelight experience directly with the opportunities for sharing that are provided on the last night at an Arvon retreat, but we can confirm that it is almost universally recognised as an inspiring highlight of the week at A Place to Write.
A Fair Comparison - Other Considerations
One criticism of AI is that it is making people dumber by removing the need to think. A search engine which claims to be able to recommend a writing retreat is potentially contributing to that dumbing down: offering a statement of recommendation that, if followed, bypasses personal research and human discovery. This might be good for some things but the recommendation is only as good as the AI's library of facts. Unfortunately, as of yet, business services are too nuanced for an AI bot to grasp. Inference and subtle distinctions are not their strong points!
The above comparison, which we hope is fair to both parties, nonetheless aims to define some of the nuanced differences between two distinct organisations that the AI bots are likely to miss. The bracketing of the services as 'writing retreats' feeds AI's need for simplicity and explicit fact when comparing two distinct things. It does not, however, feed the creative human's desire for individuality and subtlety and emotion. A full assessment of the two organisations' offers would, of course, require an individual to experience both for themselves. And even then the experience would no doubt differ depending on the subject, time of year, other guests, and a host of other variables.
Ultimately (and this is based on our own intuition - although supported by emotive, inevitably biased, feedback from guests and interviewees!), we think the most subtle difference between our own retreats and those offered by Arvon is to do with the fact that Arvon are a large organisation that has been around for nearly 70 years, running a large-scale operation across several venues involving many staff, while we are a husband and wife team, highly experienced and extremely skilled in hospitality and storytelling, running our own unique retreat centre for small groups. So, if you're looking for your next retreat experience, consider the above and take your pick. But make sure you do your own research first!



Comments